When talking about golf course living in North Naples, two names that have historically come up are Quail Creek and Quail Creek Village. Despite sharing a similar location just east of I-75 and a reputation for friendly, welcoming residents, the two communities differ greatly in lifestyles and real estate opportunities. Understanding these differences is key for buyers who want to find the best fit for their needs, and after nearly 25 years of specializing in these communities, we are here to help!
Starting off first, Quail Creek, sometimes referred to as Quail Creek Estates, is a private luxury golf community built across 650 acres in a low density 291 estate home configuration. Every residence sits on a near one acre lot, creating a rare combination of privacy, exclusivity, and tranquility. Homes in Quail Creek Naples, FL are grand in scale with many spanning over 4,000 square feet and featuring large pool areas and sweeping views. Membership at Quail Creek Country Club is optional to homeowners which appeals to both golf enthusiasts and those who simply want the estate style living without mandatory club costs.
Quail Creek Village, mainly developed by Arthur Rutenberg in the late 1980s and early 1990s, presents a more affordable and laid back version of country club living. The community features 325 “doors” meaning a mixture of villas, condominiums, and single family residences that are smaller compared to the estates of Quail Creek. Homes range in size from 1,800 square feet all the way up to 3,400. The Village centers around its own 18-hole golf course and clubhouse which fosters a strong neighborhood bond with its packed social calendar and homeowner run clubs and gatherings. Buyers drawn to Quail Creek Village Naples, FL typically appreciate its affordability for the location, convenient floor plans, and the included social membership to Quail Village Golf Club. The latter membership is perfect for those who want to enjoy golf, tennis, on property dining, and community events without the price tag or formality of a larger country club.
Going into further details, Quail Creek Country Club’s full golf membership comes at a $150,000 initiation fee cost plus annual dues in the range of $20,000. On the flip side, Quail Village golf members can save on initiation as a homeowner and annual dues for families total $6000. The two 18-hole championship courses at Quail Creek Country Club are challenging, yet fair, and play all the way up to 7,000 yards from the back tees. The course at Quail Village was uniquely planned as a par 70 consisting of six par 3s, three par 5s, and nine par 4s. Both clubs have weekly, member run leagues of all skill levels and the clubs put together numerous individual, team, and couples tournaments.
Homebuyers looking or deciding between the two will find the choice often depends on a variety of factors. Budgets, seasonal vs. full time, maintenance costs, lifestyle needs, size requirements, and privacy are all key considerations and points of difference between the two communities; either way, both embody the best of Naples golf living in distinct manners.